The Verdict Is In
So what’s up with the crayons? Everywhere cheap Canada Goose you go lately the bookstore, Starbucks even here at NPR I see grown Canada Goose Outlet men and women sitting around coloring.
Every time, canada goose black friday sale this takes me back to rainy childhood days on the living canada goose coats room canada goose clearance sale floor: A robot. A mosaic of geometric houses. A flowery design pattern.
buy canada goose jacket cheap Yup. There are thousands of titles now for every adult coloring book you could imagine, and then some. According to Canada Goose Jackets jillions of websites, coloring promotes mindfulness and reduces stress for grown ups. https://www.canadagoosejacketsoutsale.com buy canada goose jacket cheap
cheap Canada Goose Why do people like coloring so much? Do coloring books have any educational value? canada goose uk outlet Do they squash creativity like a bug or, as some sites suggest, promote the development of fine motor skills? cheap Canada Goose
Canada Goose Parka I’ve seen my canada goose store daughter bring home worksheets from elementary buy canada goose jacket school, asking her to color in this or that canada goose uk black friday picture after answering a math or word problem. And, I’ve wondered as I watched her complete these assignments, «Isn’t this busywork?» Canada Goose Parka
canada goose clearance I’ve always thought coloring books are, educationally speaking, bad news. That «staying in the lines» isn’t really the kind of independent and creative thinking we want to nurture. canada goose clearance
Canada Goose Jackets Lowenfeld was a professor at Penn State, and canada goose clearance that year he published a book called Creative and Mental Growth. Canada Goose Jackets
canada goose deals «He’s the great great grandfather of art education,» explains Melody Milbrandt, a professor of arts education at Georgia State University and the 2015 National Art Educator of the Year. She teaches art teachers, and I uk canada goose asked Canada Goose Online her to guide me through the thinking on this. canada goose deals
Canada Goose online I eventually tracked down a copy of the book. And right there on Page 176 I found a pretty good confirmation of my original impression: «There is general agreement that coloring books canada goose factory sale too are detrimental to children’s creative expression.» Canada Goose online
Canada Goose Outlet No big surprise, really. And yet, as I read that, I found myself canadian goose jacket asking: Then why is my kid bringing home these worksheets? Canada Goose Outlet
buy canada goose jacket Indeed, two pages later, Lowenfeld is astonished by this, too: «Surprisingly enough, dittoed sheets are still occasionally handed out for youngsters to color that Canada Goose sale may have outlines of George Washington, a Thanksgiving turkey, a Halloween pumpkin.»Despite, he adds, the fact that «there is no evidence that these laboriously colored balloons and kites actually help to develop either number concepts or reading abilities.» buy canada goose jacket
canada goose What surprised me the most, though, was Lowenfeld’s reasoning about why coloring books are bad at least in terms of schools and learning. canada goose
canada goose coats Page 176: «The dependency upon someone else’s outline of an object makes children much less canada goose coats on sale confident in their own means of expression. They obviously cannot draw a cow as good as the one in the coloring book.» canada goose coats
He’s basically asking the question: Why color in a ready made picture when you can create your own?
canadian goose canada goose outlet jacket Milbrandt explained this further: «When you look at a coloring book, you say, ‘Who’s making the decisions here?’ The canada goose image is already there, with uk canada goose outlet little opportunity for the child to construct meaning.» canadian goose jacket
Canada Goose sale Coloring books, writes Lowenfeld, can reinforce «stereotypes.» There’s a fascinating illustration in his book that, well, illustrates this: Canada Goose sale
Give kids a blank sheet Canada Goose Coats On Sale of paper and ask them to cheap canada goose uk draw a bird. And you’ll get all kinds of fanciful images back. But give them a coloring book where birds are drawn as two connected arcs, like a really wide and curvy «V,» and then ask them again to draw a bird on their own. Many kids will start to draw birds in that very simple, «stereotyped» way.
Milbrandt Canada Goose online picks another example: the sun. «In our culture, the sun is up in the corner, a yellow ball with yellow rays. If [children] are seeing birds or the sun represented in a particular way, they tend to adopt those as symbols. Just like some children’s literature promotes stereotypes of princesses and buy canada goose jacket cheap bad guys.»
canada goose store And, she adds, art education isn’t just about teaching kids how to draw Canada Goose Parka or paint or sculpt. «Part of what we encourage children to do through art is to construct meaning and synthesize their understandings of the world. To engage at a deeper level.» canada goose store
canada goose black friday sale Or, to put it in coloring book terms: Don’t stay in the lines. Create your own lines. canada goose black friday sale
But wait. I loved coloring when I was a kid. Isn’t coloring a fun thing that parents and kids can do together? What about those fine motor skills?
canada goose coats on sale «If the goal is for the child to develop fine motor skills and canada goose uk shop color inside the line, they may get satisfaction by doing that correctly,» Milbrandt says canada goose coats on sale.